Plugin how-tos · Guide
Smush vs ShortPixel: How Their Compression Options Compare
Short answer
Smush and ShortPixel both shrink WordPress images, but they package the choice differently. Smush gives you named levels: Basic, Super at up to twice the compression of Basic, and Ultra at up to five times Basic. ShortPixel gives you three algorithms: Lossy for the smallest files, Glossy for high-quality lossy compression aimed at photographers, and Lossless for pixel-perfect copies.
Key takeaways
- Smush offers Basic, Super and Ultra levels, with Super at up to twice the compression of Basic and Ultra at up to five times Basic.
- ShortPixel offers Lossy, Glossy and Lossless algorithms, and Glossy is its high-quality lossy option for photographers.
- Smush Pro adds WebP and AVIF conversion plus a CDN with 119 servers and up to 500 GB of bandwidth.
- ShortPixel gives 100 free credits a month, charges no credit when an image shrinks by less than 5 percent, and caps files at 100 MB.
- Smush uses fixed compression levels you pick, while ShortPixel sets the strength per image and offers no ratio slider.
What is the core difference between Smush and ShortPixel compression?
Smush gives you named compression levels called Basic, Super and Ultra, while ShortPixel gives you three named algorithms called Lossy, Glossy and Lossless.
Both plugins shrink image files so pages load faster, but they describe the choice in different ways. Smush frames it as levels of strength, and ShortPixel frames it as a balance between file size and image fidelity.
ShortPixel explains on its own blog that it offers no compression ratio slider, because its algorithms judge each image on its own. Smush takes the opposite approach and lets you pick a level up front.
Image compression is only one part of a faster site, so pair either plugin with the other speed work in our guide to speeding up WordPress.
What compression options does Smush offer?
Smush starts with lossless compression as its Basic level, then adds stronger lossy levels called Super and Ultra.
The WordPress.org listing for Smush states that the plugin compresses images with both lossless and lossy compression. Lossless strips unneeded data without changing pixel data, while lossy discards some detail to shrink files further.
WPMU DEV describes Super Smush as up to twice the compression of the Basic level, and Ultra Smush as up to 5 times the compression. Both are lossy, so each step trades a small amount of visible quality for a smaller file.
Smush also works with Elementor, WooCommerce and other common tools, according to the WordPress.org listing. If your pages are built with Elementor, see our guide to speeding up Elementor.
For the full feature list, see our Smush review.
What compression options does ShortPixel offer?
ShortPixel offers three compression algorithms: Lossy for the smallest files, Glossy for high-quality lossy compression, and Lossless for pixel-perfect copies.
The WordPress.org listing for ShortPixel describes Glossy as a high-quality lossy algorithm built for photographers and sites with high-quality product pictures. Lossy gives the largest size reductions, and Lossless keeps every pixel intact.
ShortPixel also says you cannot pick a compression ratio, because its algorithms compare each image with the original and adjust per image. That means the same setting can shrink one photo a lot and another only a little.
ShortPixel handles JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, AVIF and PDF files, and the WordPress.org listing gives a 100 MB file size limit. You can view lossy, glossy and lossless versions of an image from the Media Library with a single click. For the full feature list, see our ShortPixel review.
How do lossy, glossy and lossless differ in practice?
Lossy discards some image detail for much smaller files, lossless keeps every pixel and shrinks files less, and glossy sits between them as a gentler form of lossy.
| Option | What it does | Best for | Offered by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lossless | Keeps every pixel and removes only redundant data | Logos, screenshots and sharp graphics | Smush and ShortPixel |
| Glossy | Lossy compression tuned for high quality | Photos and product pictures | ShortPixel only |
| Lossy | Discards detail the eye may not notice | Blog photos and large photo libraries | Smush and ShortPixel |
| Super and Ultra | Smush lossy levels at up to 2x and 5x Basic | Large libraries where size matters most | Smush; Ultra is a Pro feature |
Google's web.dev guide to image formats puts the same idea in format terms: use PNG or lossless WebP when you must preserve fine detail, and JPEG, lossy WebP or AVIF for photos. It also notes that PNG applies no lossy compression beyond the palette choice, so PNG files stay large.
That advice maps neatly onto the plugins. Pick Lossless for a logo or diagram, Glossy for a product photo, and Lossy, Super or Ultra for everyday blog photos where a small quality trade is fine.
Which plugin gives you more control over compression?
Smush gives you more direct control because you pick a named level, while ShortPixel gives you less direct control because it sets the strength per image for you.
Smush lets you switch between Basic, Super and Ultra, and its docs explain that automatic compression runs on upload for every size you select. If an image is larger than 32 MB, Smush will not compress it automatically, and the docs suggest compressing it by hand instead.
ShortPixel's approach is hands-off: you pick Lossy, Glossy or Lossless, and its algorithms decide the strength for each image. Its own blog says a fixed ratio would under-compress some images and over-compress others, which is why the slider does not exist.
Neither approach is wrong; the choice is about how much you want to steer. If you like to set a level and see what happens, Smush fits. If you would rather pick a quality target and let the plugin decide, ShortPixel fits.
How do WebP and AVIF fit into each plugin?
Both plugins can create WebP and AVIF versions of your images, but Smush keeps those formats in Pro while ShortPixel includes them in its standard feature set.
Smush Pro serves WebP and AVIF to browsers that support them and falls back to the original for the rest, according to the WordPress.org listing. WPMU DEV's Smush docs add that WebP is typically 26 to 30 percent smaller than JPEG or PNG, and AVIF can be up to 60 percent smaller.
ShortPixel also converts to WebP and AVIF automatically, and it can turn animated GIFs into much smaller animated WebP or AVIF files. The WordPress.org listing notes that its SmartCompress algorithm also optimizes existing WebP files.
Smush Pro also serves images through a CDN with 119 servers and up to 500 GB of bandwidth, according to the WordPress.org listing. If you want to weigh CDN costs before you pay for one, see our guide to WordPress CDN costs.
Google's web.dev guide adds that WebP and AVIF generally compress better than older formats, so either plugin's modern-format output should beat serving plain JPEG or PNG.
What limits apply to each plugin?
Smush caps automatic compression at 32 MB per image, while ShortPixel caps files at 100 MB and charges no credit when an image shrinks by less than 5 percent.
Smush's docs state the 32 MB automatic limit plainly, so very large originals need a manual pass. Smush also backs up originals so you can restore them, and it can optimize images stored outside the Media Library through Directory Smush.
ShortPixel's WordPress.org listing gives the 100 MB limit and the 5 percent rule, and it notes that originals are backed up locally and can be restored with one click. Its optimization runs on ShortPixel's own cloud, so your hosting resources stay untouched during bulk jobs.
ShortPixel's free plan gives you 100 credits a month, and each image that shrinks by at least 5 percent uses one credit. Smush's free version has no credit system at all, which makes its limits simpler to track.
How much does each plugin cost?
ShortPixel starts free with 100 credits a month and sells unlimited monthly optimization for 9.99 dollars, while Smush is free on WordPress.org and sells its stronger options through WPMU DEV Pro plans.
The WordPress.org listing for ShortPixel lists 100 free credits per month, unlimited monthly credits for 9.99 dollars, and one-time credit packages from 19.99 dollars, as of November 2026. One-time credits never expire, according to ShortPixel's own cost comparison.
Smush Pro adds Ultra compression, WebP and AVIF conversion and the image CDN, and WPMU DEV sells it as a yearly plan. Check the current price on the vendor page before you pay, because plan prices change.
| Plugin | Free plan | Paid route, as of November 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Smush | Free on WordPress.org with lossless compression | Pro plans from WPMU DEV add Ultra, WebP, AVIF and the CDN |
| ShortPixel | 100 credits a month | Unlimited monthly credits for 9.99 dollars; one-time packs from 19.99 dollars |
Which plugin should you pick for your site?
Pick Smush if you want simple levels and no credit counting, and pick ShortPixel if you want a middle Glossy option and a credit plan that fits a small library.
Pick Smush when
- You want to set a level, Basic, Super or Ultra, and leave it alone.
- You run a large library and dislike counting credits.
- You already use other WPMU DEV tools and want one vendor for image work.
Pick ShortPixel when
- You shoot photos or sell products and want the Glossy middle option.
- Your library is small enough for 100 free credits a month.
- You prefer one-time credits that never expire over a yearly plan.
For most blogs, Smush free covers the basics and ShortPixel free covers 100 images a month, so the real split is control against credits. Photographers and shops lean toward ShortPixel for Glossy, while large libraries lean toward Smush for its flat, credit-free model.
What mistakes should you avoid?
Do not pick the strongest compression for every image, do not skip backups, and do not judge a setting from a single photo.
- Using Lossy or Ultra on logos and screenshots, where artifacts show around sharp edges.
- Compressing originals without keeping a backup, so you cannot restore the full-quality file.
- Paying for a plan before checking how many images you actually upload each month.
- Running both plugins on the same images, which can compress files twice and waste ShortPixel credits.
- Assuming a smaller file always means a faster page, when oversized dimensions can matter more.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch from Smush to ShortPixel without losing my original images?
Yes, if your originals are backed up. Both plugins keep a backup of each original, so restore your originals in the old plugin first, then deactivate it and optimize with the new one. That way the new plugin works from full-quality files instead of files that were already compressed once.
Does ShortPixel Glossy work on PNG files?
ShortPixel describes Glossy as a JPEG compression option, so it is aimed at photos rather than PNG graphics. For PNG files with sharp edges or text, Lossless is the safer pick because it keeps every pixel. You can still convert a PNG photo to JPEG or WebP if the smaller file matters more than the format.
Do I need WebP or AVIF if I already compress my JPEGs?
You do not need them, but they usually shrink files further than compressed JPEGs. Smush Pro and ShortPixel can both create WebP and AVIF versions next to your originals, and browsers that cannot use them fall back to the original. Start with one format, check a few images by eye, then roll it out.
Will image compression alone fix a slow WordPress site?
No. Compression shrinks image files, but hosting, caching, and oversized page weight also shape load time. Treat compression as one step in a wider speed plan: compress images, serve them at the right size, and fix the slowest parts of the page first.
Can I run Smush and ShortPixel on the same site?
You can install both, but you should not run both on the same images. Double compression can degrade quality and waste ShortPixel credits, since each plugin would process files the other already shrank. Pick one plugin for compression and use the other only if you need a feature the first lacks.
What happens when I run out of ShortPixel credits?
Optimization pauses until your free credits renew the next month or you buy more. One-time credit packs never expire, so they suit a site with uneven uploads. If you optimize images every month, the unlimited monthly plan removes the counting altogether.
Sources
- Smush – Image Optimization, Compression, Lazy Load, WebP & CDN WordPress.org
- ShortPixel Image Optimizer – Optimize Images, Convert WebP & AVIF WordPress.org
- Smush | WPMU DEV Documentation WPMU DEV
- How To Ace Google's Image PageSpeed Recommendations With Smush WPMU DEV
- Why you cannot choose the compression ratio with ShortPixel ShortPixel
- Choose the right image format web.dev
- Plans & Pricing ShortPixel
Is your product missing, or something out of date?
Tell us what to add or correct. We read every note and reply when we need a source. A message does not buy a ranking.
Thanks — we review requests within 3 business days.
