UpdraftPlus is the default free backup: scheduled copies to storage you control. BlogVault is the paid product we put first when a restore has to start even if wp-admin does not. They solve neighbouring problems. The expensive mistake is assuming a free archive you have never restored is a disaster plan.
The full order is in best WordPress backup plugins. Profiles: UpdraftPlus and BlogVault.
Side by side
| Criterion | UpdraftPlus | BlogVault | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Score | 8.8 | 9.3 | BlogVault |
| Price | Free plan is useful. Premium adds incrementals and migration | Paid. Trial, then a subscription | UpdraftPlus |
| Where backups run | Inside WordPress, out to your cloud | On BlogVault’s servers | BlogVault when the site is large or down |
| Restore if wp-admin is dead | You need a working site or a manual process | You can start from their cloud | BlogVault |
| Storage you control | Google Drive, Dropbox, S3 and similar | Retention lives with the vendor | UpdraftPlus |
| WooCommerce | Premium features cover more frequent backups | Paid plans can capture changes between daily runs | BlogVault for busy stores |
| Staging and migration | Premium | Included in the same product | BlogVault |
| 2026 security note | Update past the UpdraftCentral key incident | No equivalent note in our directory | BlogVault |
Choose UpdraftPlus when
You want a free schedule to a bucket you own, the site still boots, and you have actually clicked restore once on a staging copy. Update to 1.26.13 or later and revoke old UpdraftCentral keys. If the only backup is the one inside a plugin on the same server, you do not have an off-site copy yet. Point it at Drive, Dropbox or S3.
Choose BlogVault when
The site is a store or a business, backups time out inside wp-admin, or you want staging and migration in the same login. You are trusting the vendor’s cloud for retention. That is the trade for a restore that does not need the broken site to cooperate. There is no ongoing free plan. Use the trial to restore something, not only to watch a progress bar.
Verdict
Winner for sites that make money: BlogVault. Winner for a free, competent backup to storage you control: UpdraftPlus, with the October 2026 update applied. WPvivid is the other free option if you also want staging without a subscription. A host snapshot does not retire either plugin until you know the retention and you have downloaded a copy.
FAQ
Is the free UpdraftPlus plan enough?
For a scheduled copy to Google Drive, Dropbox or S3, yes. The restore still runs inside WordPress, so it fails if the site or the host is already down.
Why did UpdraftPlus need an urgent update in 2026?
In October 2026, UpdraftCentral connection keys were stolen from the vendor. Update to 1.26.13 or later and confirm old keys are revoked.
Is BlogVault worth paying for?
When the site makes money and you need incremental, off-server backups plus a restore that does not depend on wp-admin. There is no ongoing free backup plan.
Do I still need the host’s snapshot?
Yes, if the host offers one. Know the retention. A plugin backup and a host snapshot fail in different ways, which is the point of having both.