Yoast SEO is the better pick for most single sites because its free version is the most installed and Premium bundles redirects, local SEO and AI tools for $118.80 a year. Choose AIOSEO when you manage several sites or want built-in rank tracking, since its plans cover up to 100 sites.
Yoast SEO and AIOSEO are the two oldest WordPress SEO plugins, and both cover the same core job: titles, meta descriptions, sitemaps and schema. The choice comes down to price, which paid features you need, and how many sites you run.
This comparison uses each plugin's WordPress.org listing and its vendor pricing page, all read on 22 November 2026. Prices are regular renewal prices, with first-year discounts noted in the text.
Side by side
| Criterion | Yoast SEO | All in One SEO | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free version | Yes, on WordPress.org with 10M+ active installs | Yes, on WordPress.org with 2M+ active installs | Yoast SEO |
| Entry paid price | Premium at $118.80 a year for one site | Basic at $99 a year at renewal ($49.50 in year one) for one site | AIOSEO |
| Rating | 4.8/5 from 27,821 WordPress.org reviews | 4.7/5 from 5,232 WordPress.org reviews | Yoast SEO |
| Active installs | 10M+ | 2M+ | Yoast SEO |
| Redirects | Redirect manager in Premium | Automatic redirects in Basic; advanced redirects in Pro | AIOSEO |
| Local SEO | Included with Premium at no extra cost | Plus plan and up, from $199 a year at renewal | Yoast SEO |
| Internal linking | Linking suggestions in Premium | Link Assistant in Pro and up, from $399 a year at renewal | Yoast SEO |
| Rank tracking | Through a Wincher integration, not built in | Built in on Elite, from $599 a year at renewal | AIOSEO |
| AI tools | AI Generate and Optimize in Premium, with no credit limits | AI tools in paid plans with an annual credit allowance | Yoast SEO |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days on an initial purchase only | 14 days on every plan | Yoast SEO |
| Setup | Configuration wizard walks through the essentials | Setup wizard configures the essentials in under five minutes | Tie |
Pricing compared
Yoast Premium costs $118.80 a year excluding VAT for one site, and that price already includes Local, Video and News SEO. There is no multi-site discount, so each extra site needs its own subscription.
AIOSEO Basic costs $49.50 in the first year and renews at $99 a year for one site. Higher plans cover 3, 10 and 100 sites and renew at $199, $399 and $599, so agencies pay less per site as they move up. Judge both plugins by the renewal price, not the first-year discount.
What the free versions cover
Both free versions handle titles, meta descriptions, sitemaps and schema. Yoast adds readability scores and a traffic-light guide in the editor, which suits writers who want feedback while they draft.
AIOSEO's free version adds a robots.txt editor, a headline analyzer and an llms.txt generator. Its setup wizard and TruSEO checklist suit owners who want a guided start rather than a writing coach.
Where Yoast SEO is the right pick
Pick Yoast SEO when one site needs a clear writing guide and the free version already covers the basics. Its traffic-light scores and readability checks are the easiest way for a non-specialist to improve a draft before publishing.
Pay for Premium when redirects, up to five keyphrases or AI drafting will save time each week. Local, Video and News SEO come with Premium at no extra cost, so there is no second checkout for those tools.
Where AIOSEO is the right pick
Pick AIOSEO when you manage several sites or a store. One Plus licence covers three sites with Local SEO, and Pro covers ten sites with the Link Assistant, so the cost per site falls as the portfolio grows.
Choose Elite when rank tracking inside WordPress matters, since it is the only plan with Search Statistics. Budget for the $599 renewal rather than the $299.50 first year, and check the AI credit allowance before you buy.
Verdict
Winner: Yoast SEO for most sites in 2026, because the free version is the most installed and Premium bundles redirects, local SEO and AI tools for one clear price.
Choose AIOSEO when you run several sites, need built-in rank tracking, or want the cheapest first year. Its renewal prices are lower per site, but the features most buyers want sit on the higher plans.
FAQ
Is Yoast SEO better than AIOSEO?
For most single sites, yes. Yoast has more installs, a higher rating and a Premium plan that bundles local SEO and AI tools. AIOSEO is the better buy for several sites or for built-in rank tracking.
How much does AIOSEO cost after the first year?
Basic renews at $99 a year for one site, Plus at $199 for three, Pro at $399 for ten and Elite at $599 for 100 sites. The first-year prices are $49.50, $99.50, $199.50 and $299.50.
Does AIOSEO have a free version?
Yes. AIOSEO Lite is free on WordPress.org and covers titles, meta descriptions, sitemaps, schema and TruSEO checks. Paid plans add redirects, Local SEO, the Link Assistant and rank tracking.
Can I switch from Yoast SEO to AIOSEO?
Yes. AIOSEO includes an importer that moves titles, meta descriptions and settings from Yoast SEO. Back up first, import on a staging copy, and check every page before you deactivate Yoast.
Which plugin is better for a WooCommerce store?
Both handle stores, but the costs differ. Yoast WooCommerce SEO costs $178.80 a year on top of Premium, while AIOSEO includes WooCommerce SEO in its paid plans from Basic.
Do I need to pay for either plugin to rank?
No. A plugin cannot rank a page on its own. Both free versions cover the on-page basics, and paying only saves time on redirects, internal links and drafting.
Sources we checked (8)
- Yoast SEO on WordPress.org
- All in One SEO on WordPress.org
- Yoast shop (plans and pricing)
- How much does Yoast SEO cost?
- AIOSEO pricing
- AIOSEO vs SEOPress (vendor plan prices)
- All in One SEO review (WBCom Designs)
- Is All in One SEO worth it? (WPLegible)