Smush is the better pick for most WordPress sites, with a 4.8-star rating, 1 million-plus installs and unlimited free compression. Choose Imagify when you want WebP and AVIF conversion in the free plan, or one plan that covers unlimited sites.
Both plugins shrink your images so pages load faster, but they charge for different things. Smush gives unlimited free compression and sells its Pro features through a WPMU DEV membership, while Imagify sells a monthly quota that covers unlimited sites.
This comparison uses each vendor's pricing page, the WordPress.org listings and public documentation. We did not run benchmark tests, so every number below comes from a page opened on 22 November 2026.
Side by side
| Criterion | Smush | Imagify | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free version | Yes, unlimited images up to 5 MB each | Yes, 20 MB a month, about 200 images | Smush |
| Entry price | Pro Basic from $50 a year for 1 site | Growth from $59.88 a year, billed yearly | Smush |
| Rating | 4.8/5 from 6,053 WordPress.org ratings | 4.3/5 from 1,658 WordPress.org ratings | Smush |
| Key features | Compression, lazy load, bulk optimization, Directory Smush | Smart compression, WebP and AVIF in every plan, auto-resize | Imagify |
| Limits | Free skips files over 5 MB; WebP, AVIF and CDN need Pro | Free stops at 20 MB a month; 2 MB max per image | Smush |
| Support | WordPress.org forum free; 24/7 support on paid plans | Help center, docs and contact form on every plan | Smush |
| Ease of use | Works out of the box with simple settings | One-click setup with automatic Smart compression | Tie |
Pricing compared
Smush Pro is not sold on its own. It comes with a WPMU DEV Pro membership: Basic costs $50 a year for one site, Standard $75 a year for three sites and Plus $100 a year for ten sites, each with 50 GB of CDN bandwidth and 24/7 support. Every plan also unlocks the rest of the WPMU DEV Pro plugin suite.
Imagify charges by monthly quota instead of by site. Growth costs $59.88 a year when billed yearly and covers 500 MB a month on unlimited sites, while Infinite costs $119.88 a year billed yearly for unlimited images. Imagify is running a 40% off sale until 27 November 2026, so the prices on its page are lower right now; the figures here are the regular prices.
Free plans compared
Smush's free plan has no cap on the number of images, which suits blogs and small sites with large libraries. The catch is a 5 MB limit per file, so full-size photos from a modern camera are skipped unless you pay for Pro, which raises the limit to 256 MB.
Imagify's free plan covers 20 MB a month, about 200 images, on unlimited sites, with a 2 MB limit per image. Its edge is that WebP and AVIF conversion work in the free plan, so you can serve next-gen formats without paying. See how to serve images in next-gen formats for what those formats change.
Where Smush is the right pick
Pick Smush when you want a free plugin that keeps working no matter how many images you upload. Blogs, portfolios and small business sites with images under 5 MB get compression, lazy load and bulk optimization without a monthly quota to watch.
Pay for Pro when you need WebP and AVIF, a CDN and larger files. The membership also makes sense if you already use other WPMU DEV plugins, since one plan unlocks the whole suite.
Where Imagify is the right pick
Pick Imagify when you manage several sites and want one quota that covers them all. The Growth plan's 500 MB a month suits a small network of sites, and every plan includes WebP and AVIF conversion from the start.
The free plan is the better test drive if you only need a few hundred images a month. Set it up, watch the monthly usage, and upgrade only when the 20 MB limit starts to bite.
Verdict
Winner: Smush for most sites in 2026, because its 4.8-star rating, 1 million-plus installs and unlimited free compression beat Imagify on every measure that matters to a single site.
Choose Imagify when you run several sites or want WebP and AVIF without paying. Its unlimited-site plans and free next-gen conversion are the two things Smush cannot match at the same price.
FAQ
Is Smush really free?
Yes. The Smush plugin is free on WordPress.org and compresses an unlimited number of images, with lazy load and bulk optimization included. The 5 MB limit per file and the lack of WebP, AVIF and CDN features are what the paid Pro membership adds.
Is Imagify really free?
Yes, up to 20 MB of images a month, about 200 images, on unlimited websites. WebP and AVIF conversion are included in the free plan, and no credit card is needed to start.
Which plugin converts images to WebP for free?
Imagify. WebP and AVIF conversion work in every Imagify plan, including the free one. Smush keeps WebP and AVIF conversion behind its paid Pro membership.
Which is cheaper, Smush Pro or Imagify?
Smush Pro starts at $50 a year for one site through a WPMU DEV membership. Imagify Growth starts at $59.88 a year billed yearly but covers unlimited sites, so Imagify is cheaper once you pass one site.
Can I use Imagify on unlimited websites?
Yes. Every Imagify plan, including the free one, covers unlimited websites. The limit is the monthly quota: 20 MB free, 500 MB on Growth, and unlimited images on Infinite.
Sources we checked (7)
- Smush on WordPress.org
- Imagify on WordPress.org
- WPMU DEV pricing
- Imagify pricing
- Imagify homepage
- Smush documentation
- Smush free vs Pro review